Skip to content
Request a Private Briefing
MENU
Crisis Governance

Replacing the Leadership Is an Action. Proving the Culture Changed Is the Work.

5 min read

THE LEADERSHIP EDIT

By The Executor & Associates

A change of leadership is often treated as the end of a crisis. It is closer to the beginning of the real test: whether the next person who raises a concern hears something different.

On October 22, the Australian Government released an independent review of how KPMG Australia handled a whistleblower’s concerns. Its central finding was plain: “KPMG mishandled the whistleblower matter. Its response was misguided, fragmented, prolonged and, at critical points, lacked clear ownership.” [1]

KPMG accepted the findings. “The report lays bare our failings,” the firm said. [2] Its agreement not to bid for new federal work, first made in June, now runs to February 28, 2027. During that pause the firm owes the Department of Finance an implementation plan and quarterly progress reports, and Finance will assess that progress before any return. [1]

The headlines will move on. The question this case raises will not.

What KPMG Has Done Right

By most measures, KPMG Australia has done what organizations do when a crisis reaches the top. In May, the firm said its treatment of the whistleblower and the investigation “fell short,” and its chief executive resigned. [3] In June, it stepped back from new government work while it was reviewed. [4] In July, it announced its first independent chairman, subject to partner approval, plans to reshape its board with equal independent and partner representation, and a new chief executive. [5][6] It published third party reviews of its own culture, including one that describes a “say-do gap” between stated values and action. [7]

These are serious steps. They contain damage and they show consequence. They are crisis management, and they are necessary.

They are not yet proof that the culture has changed.

Reform Is Not Measured by Who Left

Leadership changes are visible. Culture is not. A new chief executive tells the market that someone was held accountable. It does not tell an employee on the third floor that raising a hard concern about a senior partner is now safe, or that it will be taken seriously.

The review points to exactly that gap. It found that culture work commissioned in 2020 had identified a reluctance to challenge senior personnel and barriers to reporting misconduct, and that there was little evidence these were addressed with sustained focus. [8] The warning signs were on paper years before the crisis became public. The structure existed. There is little evidence the behavior changed.

That is the difference between crisis management and crisis governance, and it is the line The Executor & Associates exists to define. Crisis management is one part of crisis governance. It answers the question, “What do we do now?” Crisis governance answers a harder one: “Will the next warning reach someone with the authority and the obligation to act on it?”

Five Signals That a Culture Has Changed

When an organization has apologized, changed its leaders and announced reforms, the people who matter most (regulators, clients, employees and partners) are no longer listening to what it says. They are watching what it does next. TEA’s standard for crisis governance asks for these five signals:

  • Concerns are tested for truth, not only for risk. A disclosure is first asked, “Is this true?” and only then, “What is our exposure?”
  • Someone owns the full picture. One accountable person sees each serious concern from first report to resolution, so it cannot fragment across functions.
  • Early reports rise while retaliation complaints fall. People speak up sooner because speaking up has visibly worked.
  • Senior people face the same rules. Consequences reach partners and executives on the same terms as everyone else.
  • Verification is independent and published. Progress is shown by someone outside the organization, in their words, not summarized by the organization itself.

None of these can be announced. Each one has to be demonstrated, repeatedly, over time.

The Next Test Is Already on the Calendar

For KPMG Australia, the next milestones are on the record: the implementation plan, the first quarterly report to Finance, and Finance’s assessment before February 28, 2027. Finance also expects the firm to engage constructively with reviews by ASIC and the Tax Practitioners Board. [1][2] Whether the firm earns back its standing will depend less on who now leads it than on what those reports can show.

The lesson reaches well beyond one firm or one country. Every board that has replaced a leader after a crisis faces the same quiet test. Leadership is not measured by who left. It is measured by what happens when the next person speaks.

The research behind this question, why organizations welcome ideas from their people but stay closed to their warnings, is the subject of this week’s Executor insight. Read the insight: Your Door Is Open. Your Warnings Are Not.


The Executor & Associates
executorandco.com


Sources

[1] Department of Finance, Independent Review of KPMG Australia, news release, Oct 22, 2026: https://www.finance.gov.au/about-us/news/2026/independent-review-kpmg-australia ; Finance response: https://www.finance.gov.au/sites/default/files/2026-10/2026-Finance-response-to-the-Independent-Review-of-KPMG-Australia.pdf
[2] KPMG acceptance quote as reported by Reuters (via Investing.com), Oct 22, 2026: https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/review-finds-kpmg-australia-mishandled-whistleblower-claims-pause-on-government-work-extended-4964609 ; ABC, Oct 22, 2026: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-22/audit-leaks-scandal-kpmg-ban-on-government-work-extends-to-2027/107297484
[3] KPMG statement, May 29, 2026: https://kpmg.com/au/en/media/media-releases/2026/05/investigation-into-whistleblower-allegations-29-may-2026.html ; ABC, May 29, 2026: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-05-29/kpmg-boss-resigns-over-mishandled-whistleblower-allegations/106737180
[4] Reuters, June 15, 2026: https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/kpmg-australia-barred-new-government-work-authorities-probe-audit-scandal-2026-06-15/
[5] KPMG, July 2, 2026 (first independent chairman, board composition, subject to partner approval): https://kpmg.com/au/en/media/media-releases/2026/07/kpmg-australia-announces-michael-ebeid-as-first-independent-chairman.html
[6] KPMG, July 21, 2026 (new CEO): https://kpmg.com/au/en/media/media-releases/2026/07/kpmg-australia-appoints-john-sams-as-ceo.html
[7] Principia Advisory Ethical Culture Review, published by KPMG, Oct 2026: https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmgsites/au/pdf/2026/principia-advisory-ethical-culture-review-october-2026.pdf.coredownload.inline.pdf
[8] Watt review, 2020 culture findings: https://www.finance.gov.au/sites/default/files/2026-10/Independent%20Review%20of%20KPMG.pdf ; Reuters (via Investing.com), Oct 22, 2026: https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/review-finds-kpmg-australia-mishandled-whistleblower-claims-pause-on-government-work-extended-4964609

← Back to Perspective